May 15, 2017
Fire forges historical and contemporary connections among three troubled teens. The three teen narrators could easily star in their own books. Instead, their voices and lives intertwine in an implausible plot full of coincidences and conveniently chatty villains. Rebellious white redhead Molly Mavity writes sarcastic, tense-shifting letters to her friend Pepper, who lies in a coma. Molly, whose arsonist father will soon be executed, is convinced her mother is alive--despite her suicide. Ibrahim "Pepper" Al-Yusef, a Kuwaiti immigrant with epilepsy and a comic-relief seizure pug, wryly weaves his views on everything from friendship to racism into a series of essays assigned by a long-suffering teacher as a condition of graduation. Both gradually reveal how they followed a stranger's clues to Berlin in search of Ava Dreyman, a teen from the former East Germany who became an Anne Frank-esque symbol for the fall of the Berlin Wall. Ava, whose diary of resisting the Stasi, escaping to America, and finding romance ends with her murder in 1989, connects Molly and Pepper in a far-flung way. Though Ava's accounts of oppression are chilling, Pepper's awkwardness is endearing, and Molly's grief is brutal, the mastermind's far-fetched scheme and Molly and Pepper's improbable stunts in Berlin ultimately muffle the strong voices of all three characters. A convoluted mystery that flavors the darkness of Elizabeth Wein's Code Name Verity (2012) with the contrivances of Scooby Doo. (Mystery. 14-18)
COPYRIGHT(2017) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
July 1, 2017
Gr 8 Up-Molly's 17th summer does not have an auspicious beginning. With her foot in a cast after a run-in with a train and multiple surgeries, her father's execution for committing arson scheduled in a few weeks, and her disbelief that her mother committed suicide three years ago, the teen decides that this is the summer to discover the truth about the enigmatic German dissident Ava Dreyman, whom she studied in school, and to find her mother. If Pepper Al-Yusef wants to graduate from high school, he must write a series of essays over the summer as well as deal with his epilepsy, his eccentric father, and Petra, the girl of his dreams. Molly receives a mysterious message that directs her to Pepper with the words, "He has all the answers," and Pepper decides to join her in her quest. Their odyssey to resolve Molly's questions results in Molly and Pepper learning truths about their family histories and mysteries-and a serious head injury that puts Pepper in a coma. Their stories are told through letters from Molly to Pepper as he lies in a coma, the essays Pepper writes so he can graduate, and Ava's diary. The complex plot is fraught with unlikely coincidences; dangerous confrontations, lies and secrets, and leaps back and forth in time. The unique characters and compelling stories intertwine, sometimes seamlessly and sometimes awkwardly. The lengthy volume is a page-turner with frequent surprises and a little romance. Those willing to suspend disbelief will find this an exciting read. VERDICT A strong choice for suspense and thriller collections.-Janet Hilbun, University of North Texas, Denton
Copyright 2017 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
May 1, 2017
Grades 9-12 When Ava Dreyman was killed in an East Berlin prison, all she left behind was a diary. Decades later, that diary might hold the truth about Molly Mavity's mother's disappearance, but she'll need the help of Kuwaiti American Pepper Al Yusef to unlock its secrets, and they'll have to travel all the way to Berlin and back to do it. Oakes' sophomore novel unfolds in a series of soul-bearing letters (from Molly to Pepper) and lighthearted essays (Pepper's last-chance assignment to graduate high school), all interspersed with passages from Ava's compelling diary. Though the middle drags a bit, and the ultimate reveal might be predictable to some readers, Oakes has some brilliant momentsAva's mother, a resistance fighter who burns East German buildings, gives fiery speeches about anger, destruction, and power. Molly and Pepper's lively friendship unfolds with spirited warmth, and intricate connections between their families tantalizingly come to the surface. Packed with dynamic characters, thoughtful writing, and a decades-spanning mystery, this will appeal to readers looking for something off the beaten path.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2017, American Library Association.)
January 1, 2018
Three teens' stories intersect in this convoluted mystery with an intriguing premise set alternately in 1980s Berlin and modern-day California. In the present, Molly Mavity can't escape the reputation of her arsonist father, while Pepper Al-Yusef struggles to graduate from high school. Together, they unravel the secrets behind the life and death of Ava Dreyman, an East German teen whose diary was published posthumously.
(Copyright 2018 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)